0% PFOA as a given, frying pan, misleading advertising, competition law, attorney

Misleading claims

about

by

Can a company advertise using a claim that, while true, also applies to every competing product? And does it help if half the industry advertises the same way?

“Completely safe” on the platform

On March 28, 2025, a consumer advocacy group came across an advertisement for a frying pan on a platform operator’s website. The text above a photo read

Sure!

and below that, in large letters

Completely safe.

Three dots followed, each with a check mark. Under the subheading

100% Safe Nonstick Coating

it was reported

0% PFOA, 0% lead, 0% cadmium.

In addition, the ad highlighted that the product was made in France and featured eco-friendly packaging.

PFOA stands for perfluorooctanoic acid. The substance belongs to the class of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, or PFAS for short. Its use is generally prohibited for companies in the European Union. The legal basis is the EU Regulation on Persistent Organic Pollutants (Regulation (EU) 2019/1021), into which PFOA was incorporated by Delegated Regulation (EU) 2020/784.

On May 7, 2025, the association issued a cease and desist letter to a cookware wholesaler that was alleged to have created the advertisement and made it available to the platform operator. The Ulm Regional Court granted the subsequent injunction in its ruling of April 21, 2026. The company filed an appeal against this ruling.

The company’s objections

The company did not consider itself the proper target of the claim. It argued that the platform operator was the seller of the pan, and that, if anything, an affiliated company was the one selling it to consumers. On the merits of the case, the court considered the claim to be permissible. Consumers are accustomed to seeing cookware advertised as “0% PFOA,” and competitors also advertise in this manner. Furthermore, consumers have a legitimate interest in this information.

The Stuttgart Higher Regional Court upholds the advertising ban

In its ruling dated November 5, 2026—Case No. 2 U 37/26— the Stuttgart Higher Regional Court dismissed the appeal. The company may no longer advertise the pan as PFOA-free in this manner.

Regarding liability, the court held that even the creation of an advertisement and its transmission to a third party could constitute a business act. In response to repeated inquiries from the court, the company had merely claimed lack of knowledge—that is, it neither confirmed nor denied having created the advertisement. That was not sufficient, the court ruled. A company must clarify what is happening within its own organization and corporate group before it can claim ignorance. The association’s assertion was therefore deemed to have been admitted.

Why doesn’t the blacklist apply?

The Unfair Competition Act contains, in its appendix, a so-called “blacklist” of practices that are always prohibited when dealing with consumers. In the court’s view, the association could not rely on this list.

The current regulation on advertising that takes certain facts for granted covers only consumer rights established by law, such as warranty rights. However, the ban on PFOA does not grant consumers a separate right; rather, it merely prohibits companies from using it. A corresponding application is ruled out because the European list is exhaustive.

The new Section 10a, which explicitly covers the presentation of statutory product requirements as a specific circumstance, has only been in effect since September 27, 2026. It is not applicable to this case because the conduct in question took place as early as March 2025. A claim for injunctive relief based on the risk of repetition requires that the conduct was already unlawful at the time it occurred.

When is a true statement misleading?

The court therefore bases the prohibition on the general prohibition against misleading advertising. According to this principle, even objectively accurate statements could be misleading, particularly if an advertisement emphasizes legally required characteristics in such a way that consumers assume an advantage over competing products. In doing so, the Senate follows the case law of the Federal Court of Justice regarding advertising that highlights self-evident facts.

The key factor was the overall presentation. “0% PFOA” was not hidden in the body text, but appeared under “Completely harmless” and “100% safe nonstick coating,” right next to lead and cadmium. The average consumer is aware that lead and cadmium are harmful to health. Consequently, they also associate PFOA with a health risk and consider the pan to be particularly safe. In reality, however, every company in the EU is required to avoid using PFOA.

One detail in the court’s reasoning is noteworthy. The company itself had argued that competitors also advertise their products as “PFOA-free.” In the court’s view, this effectively confirmed that the competition is also complying with the ban. This established that the practice was standard.

Does it help if the entire industry advertises this way?

No, says the court. While advertising based on self-evident facts may be permissible in exceptional cases if consumers recognize the fact as self-evident, this presupposes that they know what is at stake. That is lacking in this case.

This is because consumers are simply unaware of the chemical compound PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid) and its harmful effects on health, which led to its legal ban

A common market practice does not change this. While it may shape consumers’ perceptions, it cannot compensate for the actual design. Anyone who equates “PFOA” with lead and cadmium is implying a health benefit that the pan does not have compared to the competition.

Even the public’s interest in information could not save the advertisement . The court acknowledges that the prohibition against misleading advertising must not suppress information in which consumers have a legitimate interest. In this case, however, the pan was advertised as PFOA-free without any explanation whatsoever. Without a reference—for example, to the existing legal ban—the consumer could not critically assess the claim.

What does the new Section 10a change?

The Third Act Amending the Act Against Unfair Competition has been in effect since September 27, 2026. It implements the EmpCo Directive, which Member States are required to apply as of that date. A new entry in the so-called “black list” of the UWG is Section 10a. According to this provision, it is always prohibited to present requirements that apply by law to all products in a given product category on the EU market as a unique feature of one’s own offering to consumers.

The explanatory memorandum to the law explicitly cites as an example advertising that highlights the non-use of a chemical substance that is no longer permitted in the relevant product group anyway. At the same time, the memorandum clarifies that companies may continue to state that their product meets mandatory standards. It must simply remain clear that this does not constitute a unique selling point.

The Stuttgart Higher Regional Court does not view Section 10a as establishing a new standard of assessment. However, for advertising published on or after September 27, 2026, it significantly tightens the legal requirements. Under the blacklist ban, it no longer matters whether the statement is capable of influencing the purchase decision. Furthermore, the rule applies to all statutory product requirements, not just chemicals. It remains unclear how the courts will draw the line between permissible explanations and impermissible emphasis.

What does this mean for manufacturers and retailers?

You should check claims such as “PFOA-free,” “lead-free,” or “free of harmful substances” to see if they merely state what the law already requires of everyone. This is especially true when such claims appear in seals, checklists, or alongside terms like “safe” or “harmless.” It was precisely this combination that the court interpreted as highlighting the product’s safety.

Anyone who does not wish to omit this information should clearly label it—for example, by noting that the use of the substance is prohibited by law in the EU. Neither the Higher Regional Court of Stuttgart nor the legislature has definitively determined whether such a note is sufficient in every case.

Manufacturers and wholesalers are also responsible for promotional materials they supply to platforms or retailers. If a cease and desist letter is issued, it should be quickly determined internally who created the advertisement, as a blanket denial based on lack of knowledge will not hold up in court. This determination is the first step in any defense against a cease and desist letter under competition law.

Conclusion

The ruling makes it clear that “free of” claims regarding prohibited substances may violate competition law if they are not accompanied by an explanatory note.

Ultimately, the court did not have to decide whether the new Section 10a of the blacklist establishes a new standard and, if so, how that standard might alter the legal situation, since the violation had to be assessed under the law in effect prior to the provision’s entry into force.

We’d be happy to

advise you on

Competition law!

Our services

Consulting on Trademark Licenses

Drafting Trademark License Agreements to Ensure Legal Compliance A trademark realizes its economic value not only through its own use but also through licensing to third parties. Whether it involves merchandising, franchising, distribution partnerships, collaborations, or intra-group use of a trademark, the trademark license agreement is the tool you use to authorize and, at the same time, control the use of your trademark. It determines the revenue you generate, the extent of your control over the trademark, and whether you can terminate a licensing relationship if it is no longer viable. We support you in trademark law throughout the entire…

Mehr erfahren

Advice on non-disclosure agreement and NDA

We can advise you on all legal issues relating to NDAs and non-disclosure agreements.

Mehr erfahren

Advice on artificial intelligence

We advise you on all legal issues relating to artificial intelligence (AI). From development to training and the use of AI systems.

Mehr erfahren

GTC for e-commerce

We create, check and design customized and legally compliant GTC for your e-commerce project and advise you on all questions of GTC law.

Mehr erfahren

Advice on competition law

We advise you on all questions relating to competition law and unfair competition law, examine advertising measures and advise you on advertising measures.

Mehr erfahren

Advice on patent law

We advise you on all questions of patent law, in particular licensing and enforcement of patent claims. We work together with external patent attorneys on applications and searches.

Mehr erfahren

Relevant posts

Do you have any questions?

We are happy to help you.

Contact

Maximum file size: 10MB