
Advertisement
without
payment.
Advertisement
without
payment.
by
Does advertising without payment require disclosure if a news portal promotes restaurants and nail salons without being asked? And is the same portal allowed to use reports from the local newspaper as a free source for its own stories?
Local News Without a Local Newsroom
A publishing company in the Nuremberg metropolitan area publishes daily newspapers with numerous local sections. Online, it offers some of its content behind a paywall. According to the court’s findings, approximately 160 full-time editors and about 40 freelancers work on local coverage.
Another company operates several regional news portals. It does not employ on-site reporters; its information comes from online research.
Between May and November 2024, nine articles on local topics—which the publisher had previously covered—appeared on these websites. In addition, the website operator published five articles that featured regional businesses without any specific occasion. These featured a nail salon, a pizzeria, a sushi restaurant, a café, and a deli. To the court’s knowledge, the photo accompanying the article about the café did not even show that particular café.
The publisher issued a cease and desist letter on December 3, 2024. The website operator subsequently took the nine local articles offline. In court, the publisher demanded that she refrain from publishing its articles in a revised form in the future. It also sought to have the five promotional articles banned as hidden advertising.
The Nuremberg Higher Regional Court confirms the labeling requirement
In its judgment of October 30, 2025 (Case No. 19 O 141/25), the Nuremberg-Fürth Regional Court prohibited the publication of promotional articles without identifying them as advertisements. It otherwise dismissed the complaint.
In its appellate ruling dated May 7, 2026—Case No. 3 U 2063/25— the Nuremberg Higher Regional Court dismissed both the publisher’s appeal and the portal operator’s cross-appeal.
Why is unpaid praise considered advertising in the first place?
Anyone who writes about another company without receiving anything in return is generally not required by the Unfair Competition Act to label such content as advertising. This exception has been in effect since May 28, 2022. The court saw no way to limit this exception to press publications. The website operator had credibly demonstrated that she had received neither money nor any other consideration from the businesses. The promotion of the restaurants and studios therefore did not fall under the ban.
Instead, the court focused on the portal operator’s own business. It had published the articles to attract and retain readers. In any case, this also increased the portals’ advertising value for future advertisers. The portal operator had itself announced via email that it intended to finance itself through banner advertising in the future.
Normally, it is not a problem for a media outlet to seek to improve its market position through editorial content. This is a necessary byproduct of effective press relations. The situation is different, however, when it comes to excessively promotional content.
However, the situation is different when—as in this case—the content in question consists not of editorial material but of excessively promotional posts. In this case, a commercial act may be present, since the primary focus is on promoting one’s own competitors.
How can one recognize excessive advertising?
Excessive advertising is present when a post, based on its overall impression, appears to be unduly promotional. The court based its ruling on several factors.
There had been no newsworthy event, such as a grand opening, a change in ownership, or an award. Among many comparable businesses, only one had been mentioned in each case, without any objective reason. The articles did not contain any of the editor’s own experiences. Rather, they came across as self-promotion in a company brochure. The managing directors had admitted that they had obtained their information solely from the internet and from customer reviews. Finally, the articles had consisted exclusively of praise, contained no criticism, and used language reminiscent of advertising.
A disclosure was also not unnecessary. The promotional articles did not differ in design or presentation from the other local articles. As a result, readers only recognize the promotional nature of the content after they have already read the text. By then, they have already succumbed to the enticement. For commercial relevance, it is sufficient that a reader takes a closer look at a business—for example, by visiting its website.
Can a news portal use the local newspaper as a source of content?
On the second point of contention, the publisher lost. The court rejected any claim under competition law against the use of local news coverage as a “storehouse,” as the publisher called it.
There is no evidence of deliberate obstruction. On the contrary, anyone who draws on the local newspaper has an interest in ensuring that this source remains available. The publisher can also protect itself, for example, through paywalls and terms of use that prohibit commercial exploitation.
The court also did not find any general market disruption. It was not demonstrated that offerings with in-house local newsrooms were being driven out of the market. The purpose of fair trade law is not to protect existing business models.
Finally, it rejected the idea of providing supplementary protection for editorial work. In principle, freedom to imitate applies. Articles may be protected under copyright law, the ancillary copyright of newspaper publishers, or competition law protections against imitation. However, this must be assessed on a case-by-case basis for each article.
The fact that the plaintiff bears the costs of its local newsroom does not give it a monopoly on reporting local events.
The court added that daily news loses much of its value over time anyway. The publisher was unable to prove that the website operator had circumvented the publisher’s paywall.
Why did the publisher fail even at the motion stage?
The publisher sought a blanket injunction prohibiting the portal operator from republishing future articles in a revised form. Such a motion is inadmissible if it is based on copyright, neighboring rights, or protection against imitation. The court must compare the specific original article with the specific subsequent article in each case. This is impossible for articles that do not yet exist.
The cease and desist letter suffered from the same flaw. It made a general complaint about the reproduction of content in a “slightly edited” form and provided only examples. As a result, the website operator was unable to verify whether the allegations were justified. The cease and desist letter was therefore invalid, and the publisher had to bear the opposing party’s attorney’s fees.
What does this mean for marketing and content?
The ruling concerns a news portal. However, its reasoning is of interest to anyone who builds an audience with editorial-style content.
Providing content for free is not a free pass. According to this ruling, anyone who promotes third-party businesses to make their own offering more attractive to advertisers may be required to disclose this fact. In our assessment, it stands to reason that this ruling applies to city portals, advice websites, and similar formats that are financed through advertising or affiliate marketing. This application has not yet been clarified in court.
Those who produce editorial content should therefore verify whether a piece has a recognizable basis, whether the selection is justified, and whether it reflects their own impressions rather than promotional copy. If these elements are missing, clearly labeling the content as an advertisement provides clarity.
Conversely, for content based on third-party sources, simply rewriting third-party reports is not automatically considered unfair. However, whether a specific text is protected by copyright and whether the changes made are sufficient remains a matter to be determined on a case-by-case basis. Anyone issuing a cease and desist letter must specifically identify each instance of unauthorized reproduction that is being challenged.
Conclusion
Promotion of third-party companies provided free of charge should not be subject to disclosure requirements. However, the court concludes that such promotion is subject to disclosure requirements by taking the roundabout route of considering it self-promotion. This conclusion is understandable because readers were unable to tell that they were reading promotional content rather than news coverage.
However, this interpretation raises questions. The court also relied on the announced banner advertisement. It remains unclear how a case would be assessed if no such plans existed. It is also unclear where the line is drawn between this and a permissible restaurant recommendation, which an editorial team is, after all, entitled to endorse. .
For publishers, the second half of the ruling is sobering. According to this decision, competition law does not help against websites that rewrite local news stories. What remains are paywalls, terms of use, and proof of specific copyright infringements on a per-article basis.
We’d be happy to
advise you on
Competition law!







