Cancel button available only after subscribing, e-scooter app on smartphone, cancel button, consumer law, attorney

Cancel button

only after

by

Does an app have to display the cancellation button before the user has even booked anything? And does entering their information during registration count as payment?

E-scooters, monthly passes, and a missing button

A company rents out electric scooters and electric bicycles. Anyone who wants to ride installs the provider’s app and registers there with their personal information and a payment method. After that, they can unlock vehicles for a fee. Billing is either per ride or through various passes.

There were three options to choose from. An activation pass, available for a monthly fee, replaces the charge that would otherwise apply to each trip. A monthly subscription includes a fixed number of minutes for a flat fee. A day pass is valid for 24 hours. The activation pass and monthly subscription renew automatically; all passes can be canceled at any time.

In March and July 2023, test participants from a consumer advocacy group registered in the app. Through a menu option, they were directed to the page displaying the passes. They did not find a cancellation button there or anywhere else in the app. They did not book anything.

What does the law require?

Effective July 1, 2022, the German Civil Code requires the inclusion of a cancellation button. Anyone who enables consumers to enter into a paid continuing contractual relationship via a website must provide such a button on that site. It must be labeled “Cancel contracts here” or with an equally unambiguous phrase and must lead directly to a confirmation page. If the button is missing, the consumer may cancel the contract at any time without notice.

This requirement also constitutes a rule of market conduct under the Unfair Competition Act. Consumer advocacy groups can therefore issue cease and desist letters for violations and file lawsuits seeking an injunction.

What was the dispute about?

The association viewed the app as a violation of this obligation. After issuing a cease and desist letter that went unheeded, it filed an action for injunctive relief on August 16, 2023, and additionally demanded a flat-rate fee for the cease and desist letter.

The company countered that anyone who had booked a pass would always see a button in the app to cancel the pass. Before booking, there was simply nothing to cancel.

Federal Court of Justice Upholds Dismissal of the Lawsuit

The Munich I Regional Court had dismissed the lawsuit in its judgment of April 12, 2024 (Case No. 37 O 8961/23). The Munich Higher Regional Court dismissed the appeal in its judgment of October 23, 2025 (Case No. 6 U 1517/24 e).

In its “Cancel Button II” ruling of October 21, 2026—Case No. I ZR 243/25— the Federal Court of Justice also dismissed the association’s appeal. The lawsuit was thus unsuccessful in all three instances.

Is an app a website?

Yes. The term “website” should be understood not in technical terms, but in functional terms. It refers to any graphical user interface that enables the online exchange of contract data via installed software. A smartphone app meets this requirement.

The legislature did not define the term and left its interpretation to the courts. The issue had not yet been clarified by the highest court. The purpose of the provision supports a functional interpretation. It is intended to facilitate termination in electronic commerce, and this concern applies to apps just as much as it does to traditional websites.

The company had referred to the new cancellation button, which has been in effect since June 19, 2026. In that context, the law refers to an online user interface and explicitly includes mobile apps. In the opinion of the Federal Court of Justice (BGH), this does not imply that the older, purely national concept of a “website” should be interpreted more narrowly.

Is data considered consideration?

No. A service is considered to be provided for consideration within the meaning of the provision only if the consumer must pay money. The obligation to provide personal data is not sufficient. This question was controversial in the legal literature.

The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) acknowledges that the wording covers fees of any kind. However, it argues that the legislative history is decisive. The cancellation button was created as the counterpart to the order button in the so-called “button solution” for distance selling. The wording of that solution was explicitly tailored to payment obligations as of May 28, 2022. The cancellation button took effect a few weeks later and still used the old wording. In doing so, the legislature evidently lost sight of the amendment.

The purpose of the protection also supports this conclusion. The button is intended to protect consumers from cost traps. A cost burden that increases over time generally poses a risk only if the consumer is required to make ongoing payments. For registration, this means: Anyone who provides personal data and a payment method but has not yet committed to making a payment has not entered into a continuing contractual relationship involving consideration.

When must the button be in place?

In principle, only after the conclusion of a contract that establishes a continuing contractual relationship. The association had argued that the law is based on the mere possibility of concluding a contract. According to the Federal Court of Justice (BGH), the legislature intended something different when it used the word “enables.” It does not matter whether the specific contract being terminated was concluded online. What matters is whether the business generally offers such contracts online at the time of termination. Therefore, even contracts concluded offline can be terminated with the click of a button if it is possible to conclude them online.

Several factors suggest that the later date is correct. On the confirmation page, the consumer must clearly identify the contract, which is only possible after the contract has been concluded. The penalty of termination without notice also presupposes a terminable contract.

A consumer is only required to submit a notice of termination if he or she has entered into a continuing contractual relationship involving a service for which payment is due and from which he or she wishes to withdraw.

Furthermore, a button displayed before booking could lead users to mistakenly believe that they have already committed themselves permanently by registering. Even a precautionary termination would require that the consumer has at least made a statement indicating the conclusion of a specific contract.

Does this contradict the Higher Regional Court of Celle?

The association had cited a decision by the Higher Regional Court of Celle. According to that decision, the button on a website must be located where the conclusion of the contract is offered. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) saw no contradiction in this. Celle had addressed the location of the button, not the timing.

Furthermore, a freely accessible website differs from an app with a user profile. On an open website, the business owner cannot tell whether a visitor is already a customer. He must therefore consider the possibility that a contract has been concluded. In the app, however, the company was able to determine, based on the registration, whether a user had booked a pass and could tailor the ad accordingly.

The Federal Court of Justice did not examine whether the company actually displayed a proper button after a booking was made. That issue was not the subject of the lawsuit. Furthermore, the Higher Regional Court had not considered the association’s contrary claim to be proven.

What does this mean for app and subscription providers?

The ruling provides clarity on three points that are relevant to many business models.

  • Apps are covered. According to this ruling, anyone who sells subscriptions within an app must also provide a cancellation button within the app. The same rules apply to mobility, streaming, fitness, and educational apps as to online stores.
  • Customized display is possible. In a logged-in area, the button’s display may be linked to the booking status. The remaining requirements remain unchanged. The button must be constantly available and easily accessible, and the confirmation page must remain free of distractions.
  • Public websites are subject to stricter rules. Those who sell without requiring a login cannot determine a visitor’s status. On such sites, the button should remain visible to everyone.
  • Models funded solely by data are not covered. Free, ongoing offers that do not involve a monetary payment do not trigger the button requirement. As soon as a paid option becomes bookable online, the requirement applies to those contracts.

Whoever dynamically controls the display bears the technical risk. If the button does not appear for a customer with an active subscription, the customer faces not only a cease and desist letter but also the possibility of the contract being terminated without notice. The control logic should therefore be tested and documented in a way that is easy to understand.

Conclusion

A cancellation button for a contract that does not yet exist does not protect anyone and may even cause confusion. For businesses, the ruling is largely favorable. At the same time, the Federal Court of Justice makes it clear that apps do not create a loophole in consumer protection.

However, some questions remain unanswered. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) explicitly states that the obligation “in principle” arises only after the contract is concluded. It does not specify when this applies or what exceptions exist. It is also unclear whether the distinction between a public website and an app applies to customer accounts in a browser. In our view, the argument regarding recognizability supports this. However, this has not been definitively decided.

We take a critical view of the rationale for the fee. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) deliberately departs from the plain language of the statute and relies on a drafting error by the legislature. While this approach is methodologically defensible, it fails to account for long-term contracts that are paid for with data and can also be difficult to terminate. It is currently unclear whether the legislature will take corrective action in this regard.

We’d be happy to

advise you on

E-Commerce!

Our services

Consulting on Trademark Licenses

Drafting Trademark License Agreements to Ensure Legal Compliance A trademark realizes its economic value not only through its own use but also through licensing to third parties. Whether it involves merchandising, franchising, distribution partnerships, collaborations, or intra-group use of a trademark, the trademark license agreement is the tool you use to authorize and, at the same time, control the use of your trademark. It determines the revenue you generate, the extent of your control over the trademark, and whether you can terminate a licensing relationship if it is no longer viable. We support you in trademark law throughout the entire…

Mehr erfahren

Advice on non-disclosure agreement and NDA

We can advise you on all legal issues relating to NDAs and non-disclosure agreements.

Mehr erfahren

Advice on artificial intelligence

We advise you on all legal issues relating to artificial intelligence (AI). From development to training and the use of AI systems.

Mehr erfahren

GTC for e-commerce

We create, check and design customized and legally compliant GTC for your e-commerce project and advise you on all questions of GTC law.

Mehr erfahren

Advice on competition law

We advise you on all questions relating to competition law and unfair competition law, examine advertising measures and advise you on advertising measures.

Mehr erfahren

Advice on patent law

We advise you on all questions of patent law, in particular licensing and enforcement of patent claims. We work together with external patent attorneys on applications and searches.

Mehr erfahren

Relevant posts

Do you have any questions?

We are happy to help you.

Contact

Maximum file size: 10MB